2 10 Becoming become VBG 11 12 a a DT 13 20 captive captive NN 21 26 after after IN 27 32 being be VBG 33 41 defeated defeat VBN 42 44 in in IN 45 46 a a DT 47 50 war war NN 51 61 apparently apparently RB 62 64 is be VBZ 65 68 bad bad JJ 68 69 , , , 70 73 but but CC 74 79 being be VBG 80 83 not not RB 84 91 treated treat VBN 92 94 as as IN 95 96 a a DT 97 98 “ `` `` 98 106 prisoner prisoner NN 107 109 of of IN 110 113 war war NN 114 115 [ [ ( 115 118 POW POW NNP 118 119 ] ] ) 119 120 ” '' '' 121 123 is be VBZ 124 128 even even RB 129 134 worse worse JJR 134 135 . . . 136 141 While while IN 142 149 mankind mankind NN 150 153 has have VBZ 154 168 unquestionably unquestionably RB 169 175 become become VBN 176 180 more more RBR 181 190 civilized civilize VBN 191 195 with with IN 196 203 respect respect NN 204 206 to to TO 207 208 “ `` `` 208 220 humanitarian humanitarian JJ 221 230 treatment treatment NN 231 234 for for IN 235 239 POWs POW NNP 239 240 ” '' '' 241 246 today today NN 247 249 on on IN 250 253 the the DT 254 259 basis basis NN 260 262 of of IN 263 266 the the DT 267 277 principles principle NNS 278 280 in in IN 281 294 international international JJ 295 298 law law NN 299 301 in in IN 302 312 comparison comparison NN 313 317 with with IN 318 325 ancient ancient JJ 326 331 times time NNS 332 336 when when WRB 337 341 POWs pow NNS 342 346 were be VBD 347 358 slaughtered slaughter VBN 359 361 or or CC 362 370 enslaved enslave VBN 370 371 , , , 372 374 we we PRP 375 381 should should MD 382 387 watch watch VB 388 391 out out RP 392 395 for for IN 396 399 the the DT 400 408 possible possible JJ 409 419 regression regression NN 420 422 in in IN 423 427 this this DT 428 434 regard regard NN 434 435 . . . 442 446 Each each DT 447 451 Side Side NNP 452 455 Has Has NNP 456 457 a a DT 458 467 Different different JJ 468 473 Story story NN 474 478 with with IN 479 486 Respect respect NN 487 489 to to TO 490 493 the the DT 494 503 Treatment Treatment NNP 504 507 for for IN 508 512 POWs POW NNP 519 521 It it PRP 522 524 is be VBZ 525 533 reported report VBN 534 538 that that IN 539 542 the the DT 543 545 US US NNP 546 551 Armed Armed NNP 552 558 Forces Forces NNPS 559 562 are be VBP 563 572 regarding regard VBG 573 576 the the DT 577 585 captives captive NNS 586 594 interned intern VBN 595 597 in in IN 598 608 Guantanamo Guantanamo NNP 609 611 as as IN 612 621 dangerous dangerous JJ 622 632 terrorists terrorist NNS 633 636 and and CC 637 644 Islamic islamic JJ 645 652 Muslims Muslim NNPS 652 653 . . . 654 658 They they PRP 659 662 say say VBP 663 667 that that IN 668 673 these these DT 674 682 captives captive NNS 683 686 not not RB 687 691 only only RB 692 699 receive receive VB 700 712 humanitarian humanitarian JJ 713 722 treatment treatment NN 722 723 , , , 724 729 their their PRP$ 730 739 religious religious JJ 740 746 belief belief NN 747 749 is be VBZ 750 754 also also RB 755 764 respected respect VBN 764 765 . . . 772 775 One one CD 776 778 US US NNP 779 787 military military JJ 788 795 officer officer NN 796 798 in in IN 799 805 charge charge NN 806 808 of of IN 809 812 the the DT 813 822 prisoners prisoner NNS 822 823 ’ ' POS 824 828 camp camp NN 829 833 said say VBD 834 838 that that IN 839 842 the the DT 843 847 most most JJS 848 850 of of IN 851 854 the the DT 855 864 prisoners prisoner NNS 865 868 are be VBP 869 874 young young JJ 875 881 people people NNS 882 884 in in IN 885 890 their their PRP$ 891 894 20s 20s CD 895 897 or or CC 898 901 30s 30s CD 901 902 , , , 903 906 and and CC 907 911 that that IN 912 916 they they PRP 917 920 are be VBP 921 927 locked lock VBN 928 930 up up RP 931 941 separately separately RB 942 944 in in IN 945 950 cells cell NNS 951 954 2.5 2.5 CD 955 961 square square JJ 962 968 meters meter NNS 969 973 each each DT 973 974 . . . 975 977 He he PRP 978 982 said say VBD 983 986 the the DT 987 989 US US NNP 990 995 Armed Armed NNP 996 1002 Forces Forces NNPS 1003 1007 have have VBP 1008 1013 given give VBN 1014 1018 each each DT 1019 1027 prisoner prisoner NN 1028 1034 living live VBG 1035 1046 necessities necessity NNS 1046 1047 , , , 1048 1052 such such JJ 1053 1055 as as IN 1056 1061 towel towel NN 1061 1062 , , , 1063 1073 toothpaste toothpaste NN 1073 1074 , , , 1075 1079 soap soap NN 1079 1080 , , , 1081 1084 and and CC 1085 1092 shampoo shampoo NN 1092 1093 ; ; : 1094 1097 and and CC 1098 1102 each each DT 1103 1111 prisoner prisoner NN 1112 1115 has have VBZ 1116 1117 a a DT 1118 1122 twin twin JJ 1123 1126 bed bed NN 1127 1131 with with IN 1132 1136 soft soft JJ 1137 1145 mattress mattress NN 1146 1148 to to TO 1149 1154 sleep sleep VB 1154 1155 . . . 1156 1163 Besides besides IN 1163 1164 , , , 1165 1167 he he PRP 1168 1172 said say VBD 1172 1173 , , , 1174 1178 each each DT 1179 1187 prisoner prisoner NN 1188 1191 has have VBZ 1192 1193 a a DT 1194 1195 “ `` `` 1195 1200 Koran Koran NNP 1200 1201 ” '' '' 1202 1205 and and CC 1206 1209 can can MD 1210 1214 even even RB 1215 1222 receive receive VB 1223 1224 a a DT 1225 1228 mat mat NN 1229 1232 for for IN 1233 1239 prayer prayer NN 1239 1240 . . . 1241 1245 Lisa Lisa NNP 1246 1251 Ewing Ewing NNP 1252 1253 [ [ ( 1253 1257 name name NN 1258 1260 as as IN 1261 1275 transliterated transliterate VBN 1275 1276 ] ] ) 1276 1277 , , , 1278 1279 a a DT 1280 1286 female female JJ 1287 1289 US US NNP 1290 1296 police police NN 1297 1304 officer officer NN 1305 1308 who who WP 1309 1316 watches watch VBZ 1317 1320 the the DT 1321 1325 POWs pow NNS 1326 1330 said say VBD 1331 1333 to to TO 1334 1343 reporters reporter NNS 1343 1344 : : : 1345 1346 “ `` `` 1346 1350 Each each DT 1351 1354 day day NN 1355 1357 we we PRP 1358 1362 wake wake VBP 1363 1367 them them PRP 1368 1370 up up RP 1371 1375 when when WRB 1376 1378 it it PRP 1379 1381 is be VBZ 1382 1386 time time NN 1387 1390 for for IN 1391 1397 prayer prayer NN 1398 1401 and and CC 1402 1407 bring bring VB 1408 1412 them them PRP 1413 1422 breakfast breakfast VB 1422 1423 . . . 1423 1424 ” '' '' 1431 1434 The the DT 1435 1444 first-day first-day JJ 1445 1449 menu menu NN 1450 1453 for for IN 1454 1457 the the DT 1458 1467 prisoners prisoner NNS 1468 1473 shows show VBZ 1474 1478 that that IN 1479 1483 they they PRP 1484 1487 had have VBD 1488 1489 a a DT 1490 1497 package package NN 1498 1500 of of IN 1501 1514 vacuum-packed vacuum-packed JJ 1515 1522 Italian italian JJ 1523 1532 vegetable vegetable JJ 1533 1539 noodle noodle NN 1540 1543 and and CC 1544 1545 a a DT 1546 1553 package package NN 1554 1564 containing contain VBG 1565 1572 peanuts peanut NNS 1572 1573 , , , 1574 1581 granola granola NN 1582 1586 bars bar NNS 1586 1587 , , , 1588 1591 and and CC 1592 1593 a a DT 1594 1597 box box NN 1598 1600 of of IN 1601 1609 colorful colorful JJ 1609 1610 , , , 1611 1623 sugar-coated sugar-coated JJ 1624 1630 cereal cereal NN 1630 1631 , , , 1632 1633 a a DT 1634 1642 favorite favorite NN 1643 1645 of of IN 1646 1654 American american JJ 1655 1660 young young JJ 1661 1667 people people NNS 1667 1668 . . . 1669 1672 The the DT 1673 1677 menu menu NN 1678 1682 also also RB 1683 1691 includes include VBZ 1692 1699 oatmeal oatmeal NN 1699 1700 , , , 1701 1707 raisin raisin NN 1707 1708 , , , 1709 1715 potato potato NN 1716 1721 chips chip NNS 1722 1725 and and CC 1726 1727 a a DT 1728 1735 pretzel pretzel NN 1735 1736 . . . 1737 1742 While while IN 1743 1748 these these DT 1749 1754 foods food NNS 1755 1758 are be VBP 1759 1766 strange strange JJ 1767 1769 to to TO 1770 1773 the the DT 1774 1783 prisoners prisoner NNS 1783 1784 , , , 1785 1788 the the DT 1789 1795 United United NNP 1796 1802 States State NNPS 1803 1806 has have VBZ 1807 1813 indeed indeed RB 1814 1820 abided abide VBN 1821 1823 by by IN 1824 1827 the the DT 1828 1835 dietary dietary JJ 1836 1841 rules rule NNS 1842 1846 that that IN 1847 1854 Muslims Muslim NNPS 1855 1859 have have VBP 1860 1862 to to TO 1863 1869 follow follow VB 1869 1870 . . . 1871 1873 Of of IN 1874 1880 course course NN 1880 1881 , , , 1882 1887 there there EX 1888 1890 is be VBZ 1891 1896 clean clean JJ 1897 1902 water water NN 1903 1906 for for IN 1907 1910 the the DT 1911 1920 prisoners prisoner NNS 1921 1923 to to TO 1924 1929 drink drink VB 1929 1930 . . . 1937 1942 Under under IN 1943 1946 the the DT 1947 1954 request request NN 1955 1957 of of IN 1958 1971 organizations organization NNS 1971 1972 , , , 1973 1977 such such JJ 1978 1980 as as IN 1981 1984 the the DT 1985 1998 International International NNP 1999 2002 Red Red NNP 2003 2008 Cross Cross NNP 2008 2009 , , , 2010 2013 and and CC 2014 2017 the the DT 2018 2023 media medium NNS 2023 2024 , , , 2025 2028 the the DT 2029 2035 United United NNP 2036 2042 States State NNPS 2043 2046 let let VBD 2047 2051 them them PRP 2052 2054 go go VB 2055 2057 to to TO 2058 2068 Guantanamo Guantanamo NNP 2069 2071 to to TO 2072 2079 inspect inspect VB 2080 2083 the the DT 2084 2093 situation situation NN 2094 2096 of of IN 2097 2100 the the DT 2101 2110 detainees detainee NNS 2111 2116 there there RB 2116 2117 . . . 2118 2122 Thus thus RB 2122 2123 , , , 2124 2127 the the DT 2128 2137 prisoners prisoner NNS 2137 2138 ’ ' POS 2139 2145 living living NN 2146 2156 conditions condition NNS 2157 2159 in in IN 2160 2164 that that DT 2165 2168 day day NN 2169 2173 were be VBD 2174 2183 basically basically RB 2184 2195 transparent transparent JJ 2195 2196 . . . 2203 2205 If if IN 2206 2209 the the DT 2210 2215 above above JJ 2216 2223 reports report NNS 2224 2228 were be VBD 2229 2233 true true JJ 2233 2234 , , , 2235 2239 then then RB 2240 2243 the the DT 2244 2253 treatment treatment NN 2254 2257 for for IN 2258 2261 the the DT 2262 2271 prisoners prisoner NNS 2272 2277 would would MD 2278 2280 be be VB 2281 2287 beyond beyond IN 2288 2296 reproach reproach NN 2296 2297 . . . 2298 2305 Certain certain JJ 2306 2314 American american JJ 2315 2321 people people NNS 2322 2326 also also RB 2327 2335 maintain maintain VBP 2336 2340 that that IN 2341 2344 the the DT 2345 2347 US US NNP 2348 2351 way way NN 2352 2354 of of IN 2355 2363 treating treat VBG 2364 2367 the the DT 2368 2377 prisoners prisoner NNS 2378 2380 is be VBZ 2381 2384 not not RB 2385 2397 reproachable reproachable JJ 2397 2398 . . . 2399 2410 Christopher Christopher NNP 2410 2411 , , , 2412 2413 a a DT 2414 2423 physician physician NN 2424 2431 working work VBG 2432 2434 in in IN 2435 2438 the the DT 2439 2448 prisoners prisoner NNS 2448 2449 ’ ' POS 2450 2454 camp camp NN 2454 2455 , , , 2456 2460 said say VBD 2460 2461 : : : 2462 2463 “ `` `` 2463 2465 We we PRP 2466 2472 really really RB 2473 2478 treat treat VB 2479 2483 them them PRP 2484 2488 well well RB 2488 2489 . . . 2489 2490 ” '' '' 2497 2500 The the DT 2501 2514 international international JJ 2515 2524 community community NN 2524 2525 , , , 2526 2533 however however RB 2533 2534 , , , 2535 2538 has have VBZ 2539 2548 different different JJ 2549 2561 descriptions description NNS 2562 2565 and and CC 2566 2571 views view NNS 2572 2574 on on IN 2575 2579 this this DT 2580 2585 issue issue NN 2585 2586 . . . 2593 2594 A a DT 2595 2601 medium medium NN 2602 2605 has have VBZ 2606 2610 this this DT 2611 2622 description description NN 2623 2626 for for IN 2627 2630 the the DT 2631 2641 Guantanamo Guantanamo NNP 2642 2651 prisoners prisoner NNS 2651 2652 ’ ' POS 2653 2657 camp camp NN 2657 2658 : : : 2659 2662 The the DT 2663 2673 2.5-square 2.5-square JJ 2674 2679 meter meter NN 2680 2686 cement cement NN 2687 2691 cell cell NN 2692 2694 is be VBZ 2695 2698 way way NN 2699 2704 below below IN 2705 2708 the the DT 2709 2718 standards standard NNS 2719 2721 of of IN 2722 2727 cells cell NNS 2728 2733 built build VBN 2734 2737 for for IN 2738 2746 American american JJ 2747 2756 prisoners prisoner NNS 2756 2757 . . . 2758 2769 Fully-armed fully-armed JJ 2770 2778 watchful watchful JJ 2779 2781 US US NNP 2782 2788 prison prison NN 2789 2795 guards guard NNS 2796 2799 and and CC 2800 2805 naval naval JJ 2806 2815 personnel personnel NNS 2816 2820 make make VBP 2821 2824 the the DT 2825 2831 rounds round NNS 2832 2834 of of IN 2835 2845 inspection inspection NN 2846 2848 in in IN 2849 2852 the the DT 2853 2857 camp camp NN 2857 2858 . . . 2859 2862 The the DT 2863 2872 prisoners prisoner NNS 2872 2873 , , , 2874 2881 dressed dress VBN 2882 2884 in in IN 2885 2891 orange orange JJ 2892 2901 one-piece one-piece JJ 2902 2909 overall overall NN 2909 2910 , , , 2911 2914 are be VBP 2915 2926 hand-cuffed hand-cuffed JJ 2926 2927 . . . 2928 2933 Their their PRP$ 2934 2943 movements movement NNS 2944 2947 are be VBP 2948 2953 quite quite RB 2954 2962 confined confine VBN 2962 2963 . . . 2964 2972 Whenever whenever WRB 2973 2977 they they PRP 2978 2981 are be VBP 2982 2989 allowed allow VBN 2990 2992 to to TO 2993 2997 take take VB 2998 2999 a a DT 3000 3004 walk walk NN 3005 3012 outside outside IN 3013 3018 their their PRP$ 3019 3024 cells cell NNS 3024 3025 , , , 3026 3030 take take VBP 3031 3032 a a DT 3033 3037 bath bath NN 3038 3040 or or CC 3041 3043 go go VB 3044 3046 to to TO 3047 3050 the the DT 3051 3057 toilet toilet NN 3057 3058 , , , 3059 3064 their their PRP$ 3065 3070 hands hand NNS 3071 3074 are be VBP 3075 3080 still still RB 3081 3085 tied tie VBN 3085 3086 , , , 3087 3090 and and CC 3091 3095 they they PRP 3096 3099 are be VBP 3100 3110 supervised supervise VBN 3111 3113 on on IN 3114 3117 the the DT 3118 3121 two two CD 3122 3127 sides side NNS 3128 3130 by by IN 3131 3134 two two CD 3135 3137 US US NNP 3138 3146 soldiers soldier NNS 3146 3147 . . . 3148 3152 They they PRP 3153 3156 are be VBP 3157 3160 not not RB 3161 3168 allowed allow VBN 3169 3171 to to TO 3172 3176 look look VB 3177 3183 around around RP 3183 3184 , , , 3185 3189 talk talk NN 3189 3190 , , , 3191 3195 hear hear NN 3195 3196 , , , 3197 3199 or or CC 3200 3205 touch touch NN 3206 3214 anything anything NN 3214 3215 ; ; : 3216 3219 nor nor CC 3220 3223 are be VBP 3224 3228 they they PRP 3229 3236 allowed allow VBD 3237 3239 to to TO 3240 3244 move move VB 3245 3251 freely freely RB 3251 3252 . . . 3259 3260 A a DT 3261 3268 British british JJ 3269 3278 newspaper newspaper NN 3279 3288 maintains maintain VBZ 3289 3293 that that IN 3294 3297 the the DT 3298 3299 “ `` `` 3299 3304 X-ray x-ray JJ 3305 3311 prison prison NN 3312 3316 camp camp NN 3316 3317 ” '' '' 3318 3320 in in IN 3321 3331 Guantanamo Guantanamo NNP 3332 3334 is be VBZ 3335 3339 full full JJ 3340 3342 of of IN 3343 3344 “ `` `` 3344 3353 cruelties cruelty NNS 3353 3354 ” '' '' 3355 3358 and and CC 3359 3360 “ `` `` 3360 3367 torture torture NN 3367 3368 . . . 3368 3369 ” '' '' 3370 3377 British British NNP 3378 3387 Secretary Secretary NNP 3388 3390 of of IN 3391 3398 Foreign Foreign NNP 3399 3406 Affairs Affairs NNPS 3407 3412 Straw Straw NNP 3413 3417 said say VBD 3417 3418 : : : 3419 3420 “ `` `` 3420 3423 All all DT 3424 3433 detainees detainee NNS 3433 3434 , , , 3435 3445 regardless regardless RB 3446 3448 of of IN 3449 3454 their their PRP$ 3455 3465 identities identity NNS 3465 3466 , , , 3467 3473 should should MD 3474 3481 receive receive VB 3482 3485 the the DT 3486 3495 treatment treatment NN 3496 3498 in in IN 3499 3503 line line NN 3504 3508 with with IN 3509 3512 the the DT 3513 3525 humanitarian humanitarian JJ 3526 3532 spirit spirit NN 3533 3536 and and CC 3537 3540 the the DT 3541 3551 principles principle NNS 3552 3554 of of IN 3555 3568 international international JJ 3569 3573 law. law. NN 3573 3574 ” '' '' 3575 3578 Ann Ann NNP 3579 3584 Crawd Crawd NNP 3585 3586 [ [ ( 3586 3590 name name NN 3591 3605 transliterated transliterate VBN 3605 3606 ] ] ) 3606 3607 , , , 3608 3618 chairwoman chairwoman NN 3619 3621 of of IN 3622 3625 the the DT 3626 3628 UN UN NNP 3629 3634 Human Human NNP 3635 3641 Rights Rights NNPS 3642 3652 Commission Commission NNP 3652 3653 , , , 3654 3661 pointed point VBD 3662 3665 out out RP 3665 3666 : : : 3667 3668 “ `` `` 3668 3671 The the DT 3672 3678 United United NNP 3679 3685 States State NNPS 3686 3691 shall shall MD 3692 3695 not not RB 3696 3700 play play VB 3701 3705 with with IN 3706 3711 human human JJ 3712 3718 rights right NNS 3719 3722 and and CC 3723 3726 may may MD 3727 3730 not not RB 3731 3738 violate violate VB 3739 3742 the the DT 3743 3749 Geneva Geneva NNP 3750 3760 Convention Convention NNP 3761 3769 Relative Relative NNP 3770 3772 to to TO 3773 3776 the the DT 3777 3786 Treatment Treatment NNP 3787 3789 of of IN 3790 3799 Prisoners Prisoner NNPS 3800 3802 of of IN 3803 3806 War War NNP 3807 3811 that that IN 3812 3814 we we PRP 3815 3819 have have VBP 3820 3826 signed sign VBN 3826 3827 . . . 3827 3828 ” '' '' 3835 3837 US US NNP 3838 3846 Strategy Strategy NNP 3847 3849 – -- : 3850 3851 a a DT 3852 3860 Strategy Strategy NNP 3861 3864 for for IN 3865 3872 Testing test VBG 3873 3876 the the DT 3877 3881 Next next JJ 3882 3887 Moves move NNS 3894 3897 The the DT 3898 3900 US US NNP 3901 3905 move move NN 3906 3908 of of IN 3909 3919 disclosing disclose VBG 3920 3923 the the DT 3924 3929 state state NN 3930 3932 of of IN 3933 3936 the the DT 3937 3946 detainees detainee NNS 3947 3949 in in IN 3950 3960 Guantanamo Guantanamo NNP 3961 3964 and and CC 3965 3973 allowing allow VBG 3974 3987 international international JJ 3988 4001 organizations organization NNS 4002 4005 and and CC 4006 4009 the the DT 4010 4015 media medium NNS 4016 4018 to to TO 4019 4026 inspect inspect VB 4027 4029 is be VBZ 4030 4031 a a DT 4032 4036 wise wise JJ 4037 4040 one one CD 4040 4041 , , , 4042 4051 otherwise otherwise RB 4052 4055 the the DT 4056 4069 international international JJ 4070 4079 community community NN 4080 4084 will will MD 4085 4089 have have VB 4090 4093 all all DT 4094 4099 sorts sort NNS 4100 4102 of of IN 4103 4113 misgivings misgiving NNS 4114 4119 about about IN 4120 4123 the the DT 4124 4133 treatment treatment NN 4134 4137 for for IN 4138 4141 the the DT 4142 4151 detainees detainee NNS 4151 4152 . . . 4153 4156 But but CC 4157 4163 people people NNS 4164 4169 still still RB 4170 4178 question question VBP 4179 4182 why why WRB 4183 4186 the the DT 4187 4189 US US NNP 4190 4200 Government Government NNP 4201 4208 refuses refuse VBZ 4209 4211 to to TO 4212 4224 characterize characterize VB 4225 4228 the the DT 4229 4238 detainees detainee NNS 4239 4241 in in IN 4242 4252 Guantanamo Guantanamo NNP 4253 4255 as as IN 4256 4265 prisoners prisoner NNS 4266 4268 of of IN 4269 4272 war war NN 4273 4278 while while IN 4279 4287 claiming claim VBG 4288 4292 that that IN 4293 4296 the the DT 4297 4306 treatment treatment NN 4307 4310 for for IN 4311 4315 them them PRP 4316 4318 is be VBZ 4319 4321 in in IN 4322 4326 line line NN 4327 4331 with with IN 4332 4335 the the DT 4336 4342 Geneva Geneva NNP 4343 4353 Convention Convention NNP 4354 4356 on on IN 4357 4361 POWs POWs NNP 4361 4362 . . . 4363 4369 Basing base VBG 4370 4372 on on IN 4373 4376 the the DT 4377 4382 media medium NNS 4383 4390 reports report NNS 4390 4391 , , , 4392 4395 the the DT 4396 4398 US US NNP 4399 4409 Government Government NNP 4410 4413 has have VBZ 4414 4418 many many JJ 4419 4425 things thing NNS 4426 4428 to to TO 4429 4437 consider consider VB 4438 4440 on on IN 4441 4445 this this DT 4446 4451 issue issue NN 4451 4452 . . . 4459 4468 Evidently evidently RB 4468 4469 , , , 4470 4475 after after IN 4476 4479 the the DT 4480 4489 September September NNP 4490 4492 11 11 CD 4493 4498 pains pain NNS 4498 4499 , , , 4500 4503 the the DT 4504 4506 US US NNP 4507 4517 Government Government NNP 4518 4520 is be VBZ 4521 4530 harboring harbor VBG 4531 4535 deep deep RB 4536 4542 hatred hatre VBN 4543 4546 for for IN 4547 4552 these these DT 4553 4562 prisoners prisoner NNS 4562 4563 . . . 4564 4567 Now now RB 4568 4572 that that IN 4573 4578 these these DT 4579 4588 prisoners prisoner NNS 4589 4592 are be VBP 4593 4595 in in IN 4596 4599 its its PRP$ 4600 4605 hands hand NNS 4605 4606 , , , 4607 4609 it it PRP 4610 4612 is be VBZ 4613 4616 not not RB 4617 4623 likely likely JJ 4624 4628 that that IN 4629 4632 the the DT 4633 4635 US US NNP 4636 4646 Government Government NNP 4647 4651 will will MD 4652 4655 let let VB 4656 4660 them them PRP 4661 4664 off off RP 4665 4671 easily easily RB 4671 4672 . . . 4673 4675 It it PRP 4676 4679 may may MD 4680 4684 even even RB 4685 4689 want want VB 4690 4692 to to TO 4693 4697 seek seek VB 4698 4705 revenge revenge NN 4706 4709 and and CC 4710 4713 use use VB 4714 4718 them them PRP 4719 4721 to to TO 4722 4730 reassert reassert VB 4731 4734 its its PRP$ 4735 4744 authority authority NN 4744 4745 . . . 4746 4748 If if IN 4749 4751 it it PRP 4752 4759 chooses choose VBZ 4760 4762 to to TO 4763 4775 characterize characterize VB 4776 4781 these these DT 4782 4791 detainees detainee NNS 4792 4794 as as IN 4795 4799 POWs POW NNP 4799 4800 , , , 4801 4805 then then RB 4806 4808 it it PRP 4809 4813 must must MD 4814 4821 release release VB 4822 4826 some some DT 4827 4829 of of IN 4830 4834 them them PRP 4835 4841 sooner sooner RBR 4842 4844 or or CC 4845 4850 later later RBR 4851 4854 and and CC 4855 4857 it it PRP 4858 4860 is be VBZ 4861 4865 very very RB 4866 4872 likely likely JJ 4873 4877 that that IN 4878 4883 these these DT 4884 4890 people people NNS 4891 4895 will will MD 4896 4901 again again RB 4902 4908 attack attack VB 4909 4912 the the DT 4913 4919 United United NNP 4920 4926 States State NNPS 4927 4931 with with IN 4932 4941 terrorist terrorist JJ 4942 4947 means mean NNS 4947 4948 . . . 4955 4962 However however RB 4962 4963 , , , 4964 4971 respect respect NN 4972 4975 for for IN 4976 4981 human human JJ 4982 4985 and and CC 4986 4991 their their PRP$ 4992 4998 rights right NNS 4999 5001 is be VBZ 5002 5004 an an DT 5005 5015 expression expression NN 5016 5018 of of IN 5019 5026 mankind mankind NN 5026 5028 ’s 's POS 5029 5037 progress progress NN 5037 5038 , , , 5039 5042 and and CC 5043 5046 the the DT 5047 5053 United United NNP 5054 5060 States State NNPS 5061 5067 always always RB 5068 5079 underscores underscore VBZ 5080 5085 these these DT 5086 5092 values value NNS 5093 5096 and and CC 5097 5102 ideas idea NNS 5102 5103 . . . 5104 5111 Because because IN 5112 5115 the the DT 5116 5125 prisoners prisoner NNS 5126 5130 have have VBP 5131 5134 the the DT 5135 5139 dual dual JJ 5140 5150 identities identity NNS 5151 5156 being be VBG 5157 5160 the the DT 5161 5168 enemies enemy NNS 5169 5172 and and CC 5173 5176 the the DT 5177 5183 weaker weak JJR 5184 5191 parties party NNS 5191 5192 , , , 5193 5196 the the DT 5197 5199 US US NNP 5200 5210 Government Government NNP 5211 5215 must must MD 5216 5219 not not RB 5220 5223 act act VB 5224 5226 as as IN 5227 5229 if if IN 5230 5232 it it PRP 5233 5235 is be VBZ 5236 5243 venting vent VBG 5244 5247 its its PRP$ 5248 5256 personal personal JJ 5257 5263 grudge grudge NN 5264 5271 against against IN 5272 5276 them them PRP 5277 5282 while while IN 5283 5292 detaining detain VBG 5293 5297 them them PRP 5297 5298 . . . 5305 5310 These these DT 5311 5320 prisoners prisoner NNS 5321 5324 not not RB 5325 5329 only only RB 5330 5333 are be VBP 5334 5342 citizens citizen NNS 5343 5345 of of IN 5346 5349 the the DT 5350 5361 belligerent belligerent JJ 5362 5369 country country NN 5369 5370 , , , 5371 5374 but but CC 5375 5379 also also RB 5380 5383 are be VBP 5384 5392 citizens citizen NNS 5393 5395 of of IN 5396 5410 nonbelligerent nonbelligerent JJ 5411 5420 countries country NNS 5420 5421 , , , 5422 5426 even even RB 5427 5435 citizens citizen NNS 5436 5438 of of IN 5439 5442 the the DT 5443 5449 United United NNP 5450 5456 States State NNPS 5456 5457 ’ ' POS 5458 5464 allies ally NNS 5464 5465 , , , 5466 5470 such such JJ 5471 5473 as as IN 5474 5481 Britain Britain NNP 5481 5482 . . . 5483 5487 Thus thus RB 5487 5488 , , , 5489 5492 the the DT 5493 5499 United United NNP 5500 5506 States State NNPS 5507 5513 cannot cannot MD 5514 5520 simply simply RB 5521 5529 consider consider VB 5530 5534 this this DT 5535 5540 issue issue NN 5541 5543 as as IN 5544 5545 “ `` `` 5545 5558 contradiction contradiction NN 5559 5566 between between IN 5567 5570 the the DT 5571 5576 enemy enemy NN 5577 5580 and and CC 5581 5587 itself itself PRP 5587 5588 , , , 5588 5589 ” '' '' 5590 5592 it it PRP 5593 5597 must must MD 5598 5602 also also RB 5603 5611 consider consider VB 5612 5625 international international JJ 5626 5635 relations relation NNS 5635 5636 . . . 5643 5652 Therefore therefore RB 5652 5653 , , , 5654 5656 on on IN 5657 5660 the the DT 5661 5666 issue issue NN 5667 5669 of of IN 5670 5678 defining define VBG 5679 5684 these these DT 5685 5694 prisoners prisoner NNS 5694 5695 ’ ' POS 5696 5697 “ `` `` 5697 5703 status status NN 5703 5704 , , , 5704 5705 ” '' '' 5706 5709 the the DT 5710 5716 United United NNP 5717 5723 States State NNPS 5724 5728 must must MD 5729 5733 test test VB 5734 5737 the the DT 5738 5747 attitudes attitude NNS 5748 5750 of of IN 5751 5754 the the DT 5755 5768 international international JJ 5769 5778 community community NN 5778 5779 , , , 5780 5790 especially especially RB 5791 5794 the the DT 5795 5804 attitudes attitude NNS 5805 5807 of of IN 5808 5816 European european JJ 5817 5826 countries country NNS 5826 5827 . . . 5828 5834 Before before IN 5835 5838 the the DT 5839 5842 war war NN 5842 5843 , , , 5844 5847 the the DT 5848 5854 United United NNP 5855 5861 States State NNPS 5862 5870 appeared appear VBD 5871 5873 as as IN 5874 5876 an an DT 5877 5885 upholder upholder NN 5886 5888 of of IN 5889 5896 justice justice NN 5896 5897 ; ; : 5898 5903 while while IN 5904 5906 it it PRP 5907 5912 still still RB 5913 5918 wants want VBZ 5919 5921 to to TO 5922 5928 handle handle VB 5929 5937 problems problem NNS 5938 5942 like like IN 5943 5945 an an DT 5946 5954 upholder upholder NN 5955 5957 of of IN 5958 5965 justice justice NN 5966 5971 after after IN 5972 5975 the the DT 5976 5979 war war NN 5979 5980 , , , 5981 5983 it it PRP 5984 5988 must must MD 5989 5992 win win VB 5993 6000 support support NN 6000 6001 . . . 6008 6012 What what WP 6013 6020 appears appear VBZ 6021 6025 does do VBZ 6026 6029 not not RB 6030 6034 seem seem VB 6035 6037 to to TO 6038 6040 be be VB 6041 6045 what what WP 6046 6049 the the DT 6050 6056 United United NNP 6057 6063 States State NNPS 6064 6069 wants want VBZ 6069 6070 , , , 6071 6078 however however RB 6078 6079 . . . 6086 6089 The the DT 6090 6099 Detainees Detainees NNP 6099 6100 ’ ' POS 6101 6107 Status Status NNP 6108 6110 – -- : 6111 6113 an an DT 6114 6119 Issue Issue NNP 6120 6130 Concerning Concerning NNP 6131 6136 Their Their NNP 6137 6141 Life Life NNP 6142 6145 and and CC 6146 6151 Death Death NNP 6158 6163 After after IN 6164 6172 visiting visit VBG 6173 6176 the the DT 6177 6187 Guantanamo Guantanamo NNP 6188 6197 prisoners prisoner NNS 6197 6198 ’ ' POS 6199 6203 camp camp NN 6203 6204 , , , 6205 6209 many many JJ 6210 6223 international international JJ 6224 6237 organizations organization NNS 6238 6241 and and CC 6242 6247 media medium NNS 6248 6251 are be VBP 6252 6260 accusing accuse VBG 6261 6264 the the DT 6265 6271 United United NNP 6272 6278 States State NNPS 6279 6281 of of IN 6282 6287 being be VBG 6288 6291 too too RB 6292 6297 harsh harsh JJ 6298 6301 for for IN 6302 6305 the the DT 6306 6315 prisoners prisoner NNS 6315 6316 . . . 6317 6321 They they PRP 6322 6325 say say VBP 6326 6330 that that IN 6331 6335 that that IN 6336 6341 there there EX 6342 6345 are be VBP 6346 6349 too too RB 6350 6354 many many JJ 6355 6367 restrictions restriction NNS 6368 6370 in in IN 6371 6374 the the DT 6375 6379 camp camp NN 6379 6380 , , , 6381 6384 the the DT 6385 6390 cells cell NNS 6391 6394 are be VBP 6395 6398 too too RB 6399 6404 small small JJ 6404 6407 … ... : 6407 6411 Mary Mary NNP 6412 6420 Robinson Robinson NNP 6420 6421 , , , 6422 6428 senior senior JJ 6429 6431 UN UN NNP 6432 6439 special special JJ 6440 6452 commissioner commissioner NN 6453 6456 for for IN 6457 6462 human human JJ 6463 6469 rights right NNS 6469 6470 , , , 6471 6475 said say VBD 6475 6476 : : : 6477 6478 “ `` `` 6478 6480 We we PRP 6481 6485 must must MD 6486 6490 urge urge VB 6491 6494 the the DT 6495 6501 United United NNP 6502 6508 States State NNPS 6509 6511 to to TO 6512 6515 pay pay VB 6516 6525 attention attention NN 6526 6528 to to TO 6529 6539 respecting respect VBG 6540 6543 the the DT 6544 6555 obligations obligation NNS 6556 6566 prescribed prescribe VBN 6567 6569 in in IN 6570 6583 international international JJ 6584 6587 law law NN 6587 6588 . . . 6588 6589 ” '' '' 6596 6603 However however RB 6603 6604 , , , 6605 6610 these these DT 6611 6614 are be VBP 6615 6621 merely merely RB 6622 6633 superficial superficial JJ 6634 6640 issues issue NNS 6641 6651 concerning concern VBG 6652 6655 the the DT 6656 6666 Guantanamo Guantanamo NNP 6667 6676 detainees detainee NNS 6676 6677 . . . 6678 6681 The the DT 6682 6686 core core NN 6687 6692 issue issue NN 6693 6695 is be VBZ 6696 6703 whether whether IN 6704 6707 the the DT 6708 6715 Taliban Taliban NNP 6716 6719 and and CC 6720 6728 al-Qaeda al-Qaeda NNP 6729 6736 members member NNS 6737 6740 are be VBP 6741 6742 “ `` `` 6742 6746 POWs pow NNS 6746 6747 ” '' '' 6748 6750 or or CC 6751 6752 “ `` `` 6752 6760 unlawful unlawful JJ 6761 6771 combatants combatant NNS 6771 6772 . . . 6772 6773 ” '' '' 6780 6784 Avna Avna NNP 6785 6791 Kidlon Kidlon NNP 6792 6793 [ [ ( 6793 6797 name name NN 6798 6800 as as IN 6801 6815 transliterated transliterate VBN 6815 6816 ] ] ) 6816 6817 , , , 6818 6824 senior senior JJ 6825 6831 policy policy NN 6832 6839 advisor advisor NN 6840 6842 to to TO 6843 6850 Amnesty Amnesty NNP 6851 6864 International International NNP 6864 6865 , , , 6866 6870 said say VBD 6870 6871 : : : 6872 6873 “ `` `` 6873 6876 The the DT 6877 6883 status status NN 6884 6886 of of IN 6887 6890 the the DT 6891 6900 detainees detainee NNS 6901 6903 is be VBZ 6904 6906 an an DT 6907 6912 issue issue NN 6913 6923 concerning concern VBG 6924 6929 their their PRP$ 6930 6934 life life NN 6935 6937 or or CC 6938 6943 death death NN 6943 6944 . . . 6945 6947 If if IN 6948 6951 the the DT 6952 6958 United United NNP 6959 6965 States State NNPS 6966 6974 insisted insist VBD 6975 6979 that that IN 6980 6985 these these DT 6986 6995 prisoners prisoner NNS 6996 6999 are be VBP 7000 7002 to to TO 7003 7005 be be VB 7006 7011 tried try VBN 7012 7014 at at IN 7015 7016 a a DT 7017 7025 military military JJ 7026 7034 tribunal tribunal NN 7034 7035 , , , 7036 7038 it it PRP 7039 7041 is be VBZ 7042 7048 almost almost RB 7049 7056 certain certain JJ 7057 7061 that that IN 7062 7066 they they PRP 7067 7071 will will MD 7072 7074 be be VB 7075 7084 sentenced sentence VBN 7085 7087 to to TO 7088 7093 death death NN 7093 7094 . . . 7095 7099 This this DT 7100 7108 violates violate VBZ 7109 7112 the the DT 7113 7126 international international JJ 7127 7132 norms norm NNS 7133 7136 and and CC 7137 7139 is be VBZ 7140 7143 not not RB 7144 7146 in in IN 7147 7151 line line NN 7152 7156 with with IN 7157 7160 the the DT 7161 7167 proper proper JJ 7168 7178 procedures procedure NNS 7178 7179 . . . 7179 7180 ” '' '' 7187 7191 This this DT 7192 7194 is be VBZ 7195 7198 the the DT 7199 7203 crux crux NN 7204 7206 of of IN 7207 7210 the the DT 7211 7216 issue issue NN 7216 7217 . . . 7224 7226 US US NNP 7227 7236 Secretary Secretary NNP 7237 7239 of of IN 7240 7247 Defense Defense NNP 7248 7256 Rumsfeld Rumsfeld NNP 7257 7261 said say VBD 7262 7266 that that IN 7267 7270 the the DT 7271 7282 Afghanistan Afghanistan NNP 7282 7284 ’s 's POS 7285 7292 Taliban Taliban NNP 7293 7296 and and CC 7297 7298 “ `` `` 7298 7306 al-Qaeda al-Qaeda NNP 7306 7307 ” '' '' 7308 7315 members member NNS 7316 7319 are be VBP 7320 7321 “ `` `` 7321 7329 unlawful unlawful JJ 7330 7340 combatants combatant NNS 7340 7341 , , , 7341 7342 ” '' '' 7343 7346 not not RB 7347 7348 “ `` `` 7348 7352 POWs pow NNS 7352 7353 , , , 7353 7354 ” '' '' 7355 7358 and and CC 7359 7361 so so RB 7362 7365 the the DT 7366 7372 United United NNP 7373 7379 States State NNPS 7380 7385 would would MD 7386 7389 not not RB 7390 7395 treat treat VB 7396 7400 them them PRP 7401 7403 as as IN 7404 7408 POWs POW NNP 7409 7412 and and CC 7413 7417 they they PRP 7418 7423 would would MD 7424 7427 not not RB 7428 7433 enjoy enjoy VB 7434 7437 any any DT 7438 7444 rights right NNS 7445 7455 prescribed prescribe VBN 7456 7458 in in IN 7459 7462 the the DT 7463 7469 Geneva Geneva NNP 7470 7480 Convention Convention NNP 7481 7483 on on IN 7484 7488 POWs POWs NNP 7488 7489 . . . 7496 7506 Apparently apparently RB 7507 7510 the the DT 7511 7524 international international JJ 7525 7534 community community NN 7535 7539 does do VBZ 7540 7543 not not RB 7544 7551 support support VB 7552 7555 the the DT 7556 7558 US US NNP 7559 7568 viewpoint viewpoint NN 7569 7572 and and CC 7573 7581 measures measure NNS 7581 7582 . . . 7589 7593 This this DT 7594 7596 is be VBZ 7597 7600 the the DT 7601 7606 first first JJ 7607 7611 time time NN 7612 7614 in in IN 7615 7618 war war NN 7619 7626 history history NN 7627 7631 that that IN 7632 7633 “ `` `` 7633 7643 terrorists terrorist NNS 7643 7644 ” '' '' 7645 7649 have have VBP 7650 7656 become become VBN 7657 7660 war war NN 7661 7670 prisoners prisoner NNS 7670 7671 . . . 7672 7677 While while IN 7678 7681 the the DT 7682 7695 international international JJ 7696 7705 community community NN 7706 7710 does do VBZ 7711 7714 not not RB 7715 7719 have have VB 7720 7723 any any DT 7724 7735 universally universally RB 7736 7748 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 7749 7759 definition definition NN 7760 7763 for for IN 7764 7765 “ `` `` 7765 7774 terrorist terrorist JJ 7774 7775 , , , 7775 7776 ” '' '' 7777 7782 there there EX 7783 7785 is be VBZ 7786 7790 also also RB 7791 7794 not not RB 7795 7798 any any DT 7799 7810 established established JJ 7811 7820 provision provision NN 7821 7823 in in IN 7824 7837 international international JJ 7838 7841 law law NN 7842 7845 for for IN 7846 7855 assessing assess VBG 7856 7859 the the DT 7860 7871 punishments punishment NNS 7872 7875 for for IN 7876 7877 “ `` `` 7877 7887 terrorists terrorist NNS 7887 7888 . . . 7888 7889 ” '' '' 7890 7892 In in IN 7893 7903 particular particular JJ 7903 7904 , , , 7905 7910 there there EX 7911 7913 is be VBZ 7914 7917 not not RB 7918 7921 any any DT 7922 7932 precedence precedence NN 7933 7935 to to TO 7936 7938 be be VB 7939 7943 used use VBN 7944 7946 as as IN 7947 7956 reference reference NN 7956 7957 . . . 7964 7967 One one CD 7968 7973 thing thing NN 7974 7977 the the DT 7978 7991 international international JJ 7992 8001 community community NN 8002 8007 feels feel NNS 8008 8024 incomprehensible incomprehensible JJ 8025 8027 is be VBZ 8028 8032 that that IN 8033 8036 why why WRB 8037 8040 are be VBP 8041 8046 these these DT 8047 8054 Taliban Taliban NNP 8055 8058 and and CC 8059 8060 “ `` `` 8060 8068 al-Qaeda al-Qaeda NNP 8068 8069 ” '' '' 8070 8077 members member NNS 8078 8081 not not RB 8082 8092 considered consider VBN 8093 8095 as as IN 8096 8100 POWs pow NNS 8101 8106 since since IN 8106 8107 , , , 8108 8114 before before IN 8115 8118 the the DT 8119 8122 war war NN 8123 8127 they they PRP 8128 8132 were be VBD 8133 8142 organized organize VBN 8143 8153 combatants combatant NNS 8153 8154 , , , 8155 8158 the the DT 8159 8166 battles battle NNS 8167 8171 they they PRP 8172 8178 fought fight VBD 8179 8183 were be VBD 8184 8188 also also RB 8189 8198 organized organize VBN 8199 8209 resistance resistance NN 8209 8210 , , , 8211 8214 and and CC 8215 8219 they they PRP 8220 8224 were be VBD 8225 8234 obviously obviously RB 8235 8243 captured capture VBN 8244 8246 in in IN 8247 8254 battles battle NNS 8255 8261 during during IN 8262 8265 the the DT 8266 8269 war war NN 8269 8270 ? ? . 8277 8285 Moreover moreover RB 8285 8286 , , , 8287 8290 the the DT 8291 8298 Taliban Taliban NNP 8299 8302 and and CC 8303 8304 “ `` `` 8304 8312 al-Qaeda al-Qaeda NNP 8312 8313 ” '' '' 8314 8321 members member NNS 8322 8326 came come VBD 8327 8331 from from IN 8332 8336 many many JJ 8337 8346 countries country NNS 8347 8349 in in IN 8350 8353 the the DT 8354 8359 world world NN 8360 8363 and and CC 8364 8367 the the DT 8368 8369 “ `` `` 8369 8372 POW POW NNP 8372 8373 ” '' '' 8374 8379 issue issue NN 8380 8388 involves involve VBZ 8389 8392 the the DT 8393 8397 laws law NNS 8398 8401 and and CC 8402 8409 dignity dignity NN 8410 8412 of of IN 8413 8417 many many JJ 8418 8427 countries country NNS 8427 8428 . . . 8429 8433 What what WP 8434 8441 worries worry VBZ 8442 8445 the the DT 8446 8450 West West NNP 8451 8454 and and CC 8455 8459 some some DT 8460 8465 other other JJ 8466 8475 countries country NNS 8476 8480 most most RBS 8481 8483 is be VBZ 8484 8488 that that IN 8488 8489 , , , 8490 8492 if if IN 8493 8496 the the DT 8497 8503 United United NNP 8504 8510 States State NNPS 8511 8518 refuses refuse VBZ 8519 8521 to to TO 8522 8527 treat treat VB 8528 8533 these these DT 8534 8543 detainees detainee NNS 8544 8546 as as IN 8547 8551 POWs POW NNP 8551 8552 , , , 8553 8557 then then RB 8558 8563 their their PRP$ 8564 8572 soldiers soldier NNS 8573 8576 may may MD 8577 8579 be be VB 8580 8587 treated treat VBN 8588 8591 the the DT 8592 8596 same same JJ 8597 8600 way way NN 8601 8603 as as IN 8604 8607 the the DT 8608 8618 Guantanamo Guantanamo NNP 8619 8628 prisoners prisoner NNS 8629 8635 should should MD 8636 8640 they they PRP 8641 8643 be be VB 8644 8652 captured capture VBN 8653 8655 by by IN 8656 8659 the the DT 8660 8667 Taliban Taliban NNP 8668 8676 remnants remnant NNS 8677 8680 and and CC 8681 8686 other other JJ 8687 8694 radical radical NN 8695 8708 organizations organization NNS 8709 8713 when when WRB 8714 8718 they they PRP 8719 8723 take take VBP 8724 8728 part part NN 8729 8731 in in IN 8732 8735 the the DT 8736 8742 United United NNP 8743 8750 Nations Nation NNPS 8750 8751 ’ ' POS 8752 8765 peace-keeping peace-keeping JJ 8766 8774 missions mission NNS 8774 8775 . . . 8782 8789 Without without IN 8790 8791 a a DT 8792 8797 doubt doubt NN 8797 8798 , , , 8799 8802 the the DT 8803 8809 United United NNP 8810 8816 States States NNP 8816 8817 ’ ' POS 8818 8819 “ `` `` 8819 8830 willfulness willfulness NN 8830 8831 ” '' '' 8832 8834 is be VBZ 8835 8839 what what WP 8840 8843 has have VBZ 8844 8851 greatly greatly RB 8852 8859 annoyed annoy VBN 8860 8864 some some DT 8865 8874 countries country NNS 8875 8878 and and CC 8879 8892 international international JJ 8893 8906 organizations organization NNS 8906 8907 . . . 8908 8914 Before before IN 8915 8918 the the DT 8919 8922 war war NN 8922 8923 , , , 8924 8926 US US NNP 8927 8936 President President NNP 8937 8941 Bush Bush NNP 8941 8942 , , , 8943 8945 in in IN 8946 8949 his his PRP$ 8950 8953 war war NN 8954 8966 mobilization mobilization NN 8967 8973 speech speech NN 8973 8974 , , , 8975 8983 declared declare VBD 8984 8988 that that IN 8989 8992 the the DT 8993 9000 country country NN 9001 9004 was be VBD 9005 9007 in in IN 9008 9009 a a DT 9010 9015 state state NN 9016 9018 of of IN 9019 9022 war war NN 9022 9023 . . . 9024 9028 What what WP 9029 9037 followed follow VBD 9038 9041 was be VBD 9042 9045 the the DT 9046 9057 Afghanistan Afghanistan NNP 9058 9061 war war NN 9061 9062 . . . 9063 9068 After after IN 9069 9076 winning win VBG 9077 9080 the the DT 9081 9084 war war NN 9084 9085 , , , 9086 9089 the the DT 9090 9092 US US NNP 9093 9103 Government Government NNP 9104 9107 has have VBZ 9108 9112 come come VBN 9113 9115 up up RP 9116 9120 with with IN 9121 9125 many many JJ 9126 9131 other other JJ 9132 9139 excuses excuse NNS 9140 9142 to to TO 9143 9147 deny deny VB 9148 9151 the the DT 9152 9160 captives captive NNS 9160 9161 ’ ' POS 9162 9165 POW POW NNP 9166 9172 status status NN 9172 9173 . . . 9180 9184 Thus thus RB 9184 9185 , , , 9186 9190 even even RB 9191 9197 though though IN 9198 9203 Uncle Uncle NNP 9204 9207 Sam Sam NNP 9207 9209 ’s 's POS 9210 9217 certain certain JJ 9218 9225 worries worry NNS 9226 9229 are be VBP 9230 9239 justified justified JJ 9239 9240 , , , 9241 9244 his his PRP$ 9245 9254 hegemonic hegemonic JJ 9255 9258 way way NN 9259 9261 of of IN 9262 9269 setting set VBG 9270 9273 the the DT 9274 9279 rules rule NNS 9280 9283 all all DT 9284 9286 by by IN 9287 9294 himself himself PRP 9295 9297 is be VBZ 9298 9304 hardly hardly RB 9305 9315 convincing convincing JJ 9315 9316 . . . 9317 9319 If if IN 9320 9323 the the DT 9324 9330 United United NNP 9331 9337 States State NNPS 9338 9345 chooses choose VBZ 9346 9348 to to TO 9349 9358 disregard disregard VB 9359 9362 the the DT 9363 9369 Geneva Geneva NNP 9370 9380 Convention Convention NNP 9381 9384 the the DT 9385 9388 way way NN 9389 9391 it it PRP 9392 9399 follows follow VBZ 9400 9404 this this DT 9405 9409 time time NN 9409 9410 , , , 9411 9414 the the DT 9415 9423 legality legality NN 9424 9427 and and CC 9428 9436 sanctity sanctity NN 9437 9439 of of IN 9440 9453 international international JJ 9454 9457 law law NN 9458 9462 will will MD 9463 9465 be be VB 9466 9479 substantially substantially RB 9480 9487 reduced reduce VBN 9487 9488 . . . 9489 9491 If if IN 9492 9499 similar similar JJ 9500 9508 problems problem NNS 9509 9514 occur occur VBP 9515 9517 in in IN 9518 9521 the the DT 9522 9528 future future JJ 9528 9529 , , , 9530 9535 other other JJ 9536 9545 countries country NNS 9546 9550 will will MD 9551 9555 have have VB 9556 9558 no no DT 9559 9583 universally-acknowledged universally-acknowledged JJ 9584 9589 rules rule NNS 9590 9592 to to TO 9593 9599 follow follow VB 9599 9600 . . . 9607 9613 Taking take VBG 9614 9619 these these DT 9620 9627 factors factor NNS 9628 9632 into into IN 9633 9646 consideration consideration NN 9646 9647 , , , 9648 9654 Powell Powell NNP 9654 9655 , , , 9656 9657 a a DT 9658 9672 soldier-turned soldier-turned JJ 9673 9682 statesman statesman NN 9683 9686 and and CC 9687 9688 a a DT 9689 9697 moderate moderate JJ 9697 9698 , , , 9699 9706 advised advise VBD 9707 9711 Bush Bush NNP 9711 9712 : : : 9713 9715 We we PRP 9716 9721 might might MD 9722 9724 as as RB 9725 9729 well well RB 9730 9734 give give VB 9735 9738 the the DT 9739 9749 Guantanamo Guantanamo NNP 9750 9759 detainees detainee VBZ 9760 9763 the the DT 9764 9767 POW POW NNP 9768 9774 status status NN 9774 9775 . . . 9782 9793 Promulgated promulgate VBN 9794 9796 in in IN 9797 9799 12 12 CD 9800 9806 August August NNP 9807 9811 1949 1949 CD 9811 9812 , , , 9813 9816 the the DT 9817 9823 Geneva Geneva NNP 9824 9827 POW POW NNP 9828 9838 Convention Convention NNP 9839 9845 became become VBD 9846 9855 effective effective JJ 9856 9858 on on IN 9859 9861 21 21 CD 9862 9869 October October NNP 9870 9874 1950 1950 CD 9874 9875 . . . 9876 9879 The the DT 9880 9886 United United NNP 9887 9893 States State NNPS 9894 9896 is be VBZ 9897 9900 one one CD 9901 9903 of of IN 9904 9907 the the DT 9908 9919 signatories signatory NNS 9919 9920 . . . 9921 9924 The the DT 9925 9935 convention convention NN 9936 9939 has have VBZ 9940 9949 specified specify VBN 9950 9953 the the DT 9954 9963 treatment treatment NN 9964 9967 for for IN 9968 9972 POWs POW NNP 9973 9976 and and CC 9977 9982 their their PRP$ 9983 9993 privileges privilege NNS 9993 9994 . . . 9995 9998 Now now RB 9999 10002 let let VB 10003 10005 us us PRP 10006 10013 compare compare VB 10014 10017 the the DT 10018 10028 convention convention NN 10028 10030 ’s 's POS 10031 10041 provisions provision NNS 10042 10045 and and CC 10046 10049 the the DT 10050 10055 media medium NNS 10055 10057 ’s 's POS 10058 10070 descriptions description NNS 10071 10073 of of IN 10074 10077 the the DT 10078 10087 detainees detainee NNS 10088 10090 in in IN 10091 10096 terms term NNS 10097 10099 of of IN 10100 10105 their their PRP$ 10106 10113 dignity dignity NN 10113 10114 , , , 10115 10122 lodging lodging NN 10122 10123 , , , 10124 10132 clothing clothing NN 10132 10133 , , , 10134 10144 activities activity NNS 10145 10148 and and CC 10149 10154 trial trial NN 10154 10155 . . . 10162 10165 The the DT 10166 10173 current current JJ 10174 10183 treatment treatment NN 10184 10187 for for IN 10188 10191 the the DT 10192 10201 detainees detainee NNS 10201 10202 : : : 10209 10212 The the DT 10213 10222 prisoners prisoner NNS 10223 10227 were be VBD 10228 10235 brought bring VBN 10236 10238 to to TO 10239 10242 the the DT 10243 10250 prisons prison NNS 10251 10253 in in IN 10254 10255 a a DT 10256 10262 brutal brutal JJ 10263 10269 manner manner NN 10269 10270 . . . 10271 10274 The the DT 10275 10283 pictures picture NNS 10284 10291 clearly clearly RB 10292 10296 show show VBP 10297 10301 that that IN 10302 10305 the the DT 10306 10315 prisoners prisoner NNS 10316 10318 in in IN 10319 10325 orange orange JJ 10326 10335 one-piece one-piece JJ 10336 10343 overall overall NN 10344 10347 are be VBP 10348 10360 blind-folded blind-folded JJ 10361 10363 by by IN 10364 10369 thick thick JJ 10370 10375 black black JJ 10376 10382 cloths cloth NNS 10382 10383 , , , 10384 10389 their their PRP$ 10390 10395 hands hand NNS 10396 10399 and and CC 10400 10404 feet foot NNS 10405 10408 are be VBP 10409 10413 tied tie VBN 10414 10416 up up RP 10416 10417 , , , 10418 10421 and and CC 10422 10426 they they PRP 10427 10431 were be VBD 10432 10440 kneeling kneel VBG 10441 10443 on on IN 10444 10447 the the DT 10448 10454 ground ground NN 10454 10455 . . . 10462 10466 Each each DT 10467 10475 prisoner prisoner NN 10476 10478 is be VBZ 10479 10487 interned intern VBN 10488 10490 in in IN 10491 10492 a a DT 10493 10497 cell cell NN 10498 10502 that that WDT 10503 10505 is be VBZ 10506 10509 2.5 2.5 CD 10510 10516 square square JJ 10517 10523 meters meter NNS 10524 10526 in in IN 10527 10531 size size NN 10531 10532 . . . 10533 10537 This this DT 10538 10544 little little JJ 10545 10549 cell cell NN 10550 10554 will will MD 10555 10560 house house VB 10561 10564 two two CD 10565 10567 or or CC 10568 10572 more more JJR 10573 10582 prisoners prisoner NNS 10583 10587 with with IN 10588 10591 the the DT 10592 10599 arrival arrival NN 10600 10602 of of IN 10603 10607 more more JJR 10608 10616 captives captive NNS 10617 10619 in in IN 10620 10623 the the DT 10624 10630 future future NN 10630 10631 . . . 10632 10635 The the DT 10636 10640 camp camp NN 10640 10642 ’s 's POS 10643 10654 temperature temperature NN 10655 10658 has have VBZ 10659 10667 exceeded exceed VBN 10668 10670 32 32 CD 10671 10678 degrees degree NNS 10679 10686 Celsius Celsius NNP 10686 10687 . . . 10694 10697 The the DT 10698 10707 prisoners prisoner NNS 10707 10708 ’ ' POS 10709 10714 hands hand NNS 10715 10718 and and CC 10719 10723 feet foot NNS 10724 10727 are be VBP 10728 10736 shackled shackle VBN 10736 10737 . . . 10738 10741 The the DT 10742 10751 prisoners prisoner NNS 10752 10754 in in IN 10755 10758 the the DT 10759 10765 orange orange NN 10766 10775 one-piece one-piece JJ 10776 10783 overall overall RB 10784 10787 not not RB 10788 10792 only only RB 10793 10799 cannot cannot MD 10800 10804 move move VB 10805 10811 freely freely RB 10811 10812 , , , 10813 10816 but but CC 10817 10821 they they PRP 10822 10825 may may MD 10826 10829 not not RB 10830 10832 be be VB 10833 10837 able able JJ 10838 10840 to to TO 10841 10848 breathe breathe VB 10849 10857 normally normally RB 10857 10858 . . . 10865 10868 The the DT 10869 10875 entire entire JJ 10876 10880 camp camp NN 10881 10883 is be VBZ 10884 10894 surrounded surround VBN 10895 10897 by by IN 10898 10904 fences fence NNS 10904 10905 . . . 10906 10911 There there EX 10912 10915 are be VBP 10916 10927 watchtowers watchtower NNS 10928 10930 at at IN 10931 10934 its its PRP$ 10935 10939 four four CD 10940 10947 corners corner NNS 10947 10948 . . . 10949 10953 When when WRB 10954 10957 the the DT 10958 10967 prisoners prisoner NNS 10968 10971 are be VBP 10972 10975 let let VB 10976 10979 out out RP 10980 10983 for for IN 10984 10992 exercise exercise NN 10992 10993 , , , 10994 10998 take take VB 10999 11000 a a DT 11001 11005 bath bath NN 11005 11006 , , , 11007 11009 or or CC 11010 11012 go go VB 11013 11015 to to TO 11016 11019 the the DT 11020 11026 toilet toilet NN 11026 11027 , , , 11028 11033 their their PRP$ 11034 11039 hands hand NNS 11040 11044 must must MD 11045 11050 still still RB 11051 11053 be be VB 11054 11058 tied tie VBN 11059 11061 up up RP 11061 11062 , , , 11063 11066 and and CC 11067 11070 two two CD 11071 11073 US US NNP 11074 11082 soldiers soldier NNS 11083 11087 will will MD 11088 11097 accompany accompany VB 11098 11102 them them PRP 11102 11103 . . . 11104 11109 These these DT 11110 11119 detainees detainee NNS 11120 11123 are be VBP 11124 11134 instructed instruct VBN 11135 11138 not not RB 11139 11141 to to TO 11142 11146 look look VB 11147 11153 around around RP 11153 11154 , , , 11155 11158 not not RB 11159 11161 to to TO 11162 11166 talk talk VB 11166 11167 , , , 11168 11171 not not RB 11172 11174 to to TO 11175 11181 listen listen VB 11181 11182 , , , 11183 11186 and and CC 11187 11190 not not RB 11191 11193 to to TO 11194 11199 touch touch VB 11200 11208 anything anything NN 11208 11209 . . . 11210 11212 In in IN 11213 11218 short short JJ 11218 11219 , , , 11220 11224 they they PRP 11225 11228 are be VBP 11229 11232 not not RB 11233 11240 allowed allow VBN 11241 11243 to to TO 11244 11248 move move VB 11249 11255 freely freely RB 11255 11256 . . . 11263 11266 One one CD 11267 11275 military military JJ 11276 11284 tribunal tribunal NN 11285 11289 will will MD 11290 11293 try try VB 11294 11299 these these DT 11300 11309 prisoners prisoner NNS 11309 11310 . . . 11311 11316 There there EX 11317 11321 will will MD 11322 11325 not not RB 11326 11328 be be VB 11329 11330 a a DT 11331 11335 jury jury NN 11335 11336 , , , 11337 11340 and and CC 11341 11346 these these DT 11347 11355 captives captive NNS 11356 11359 may may MD 11360 11363 not not RB 11364 11370 appeal appeal VB 11370 11371 . . . 11378 11381 The the DT 11382 11392 Convention Convention NNP 11392 11394 ’s 's POS 11395 11405 provisions provision NNS 11406 11409 are be VBP 11409 11410 : : : 11417 11421 POWs POW NNP 11422 11427 shall shall MD 11428 11430 be be VB 11431 11440 protected protect VBN 11441 11446 under under IN 11447 11450 all all DT 11451 11464 circumstances circumstance NNS 11464 11465 . . . 11466 11470 They they PRP 11471 11476 shall shall MD 11477 11484 receive receive VB 11485 11497 humanitarian humanitarian JJ 11498 11507 treatment treatment NN 11507 11508 , , , 11509 11512 and and CC 11513 11517 they they PRP 11518 11523 shall shall MD 11524 11534 especially especially RB 11535 11538 not not RB 11539 11541 be be VB 11542 11551 subjected subject VBN 11552 11554 to to TO 11555 11558 any any DT 11559 11566 outrage outrage NN 11566 11567 , , , 11568 11576 coercion coercion NN 11577 11580 and and CC 11581 11592 humiliation humiliation NN 11592 11593 , , , 11594 11596 or or CC 11597 11607 harassment harassment NN 11608 11610 by by IN 11611 11614 the the DT 11615 11622 curious curious JJ 11623 11629 public public NN 11629 11630 . . . 11631 11639 Reprisal Reprisal NNP 11640 11647 against against IN 11648 11651 the the DT 11652 11661 prisoners prisoner NNS 11662 11664 of of IN 11665 11668 war war NN 11669 11674 shall shall MD 11675 11677 be be VB 11678 11688 prohibited prohibit VBN 11688 11689 . . . 11696 11703 Housing Housing NNP 11704 11714 conditions condition NNS 11715 11718 for for IN 11719 11723 POWs POW NNP 11724 11730 should should MD 11731 11733 be be VB 11734 11737 the the DT 11738 11742 same same JJ 11743 11745 as as IN 11746 11751 those those DT 11752 11754 of of IN 11755 11758 the the DT 11759 11765 troops troop NNS 11766 11776 stationing station VBG 11777 11779 in in IN 11780 11783 the the DT 11784 11793 Detaining Detaining NNP 11794 11799 Power Power NNP 11800 11802 in in IN 11803 11806 the the DT 11807 11811 same same JJ 11812 11816 area area NN 11816 11817 . . . 11818 11822 This this DT 11823 11832 provision provision NN 11833 11838 shall shall MD 11839 11841 be be VB 11842 11852 applicable applicable JJ 11853 11855 in in IN 11856 11860 POWs POW NNP 11860 11861 ’ ' POS 11862 11873 dormitories dormitory NNS 11873 11874 , , , 11875 11879 such such JJ 11880 11882 as as IN 11883 11886 the the DT 11887 11892 total total JJ 11893 11897 area area NN 11898 11901 and and CC 11902 11905 the the DT 11906 11913 minimum minimum JJ 11914 11919 cubic cubic JJ 11920 11925 space space NN 11925 11926 . . . 11933 11941 Clothing Clothing NNP 11941 11942 , , , 11943 11952 underwear underwear NN 11952 11953 , , , 11954 11957 and and CC 11958 11966 footwear footwear NN 11967 11972 shall shall MD 11973 11975 be be VB 11976 11984 supplied supply VBN 11985 11987 to to TO 11988 11992 POWs pow NNS 11993 11995 in in IN 11996 12006 sufficient sufficient JJ 12007 12015 quantity quantity NN 12016 12018 by by IN 12019 12022 the the DT 12023 12032 Detaining Detaining NNP 12033 12038 Power Power NNP 12038 12039 ; ; : 12040 12043 and and CC 12044 12048 they they PRP 12049 12053 must must MD 12054 12056 be be VB 12057 12065 adequate adequate JJ 12066 12069 for for IN 12070 12078 ensuring ensure VBG 12079 12083 POWs POW NNP 12083 12084 ’ ' POS 12085 12091 health health NN 12091 12092 . . . 12099 12103 POWs POW NNP 12104 12109 shall shall MD 12110 12114 have have VB 12115 12118 the the DT 12119 12130 opportunity opportunity NN 12131 12133 to to TO 12134 12142 exercise exercise VB 12142 12143 . . . 12144 12147 The the DT 12148 12156 exercise exercise NN 12157 12163 should should MD 12164 12171 include include VB 12172 12178 sports sport NNS 12178 12179 , , , 12180 12185 games game NNS 12186 12189 and and CC 12190 12197 outdoor outdoor JJ 12198 12208 activities activity NNS 12208 12209 . . . 12210 12213 All all PDT 12214 12217 the the DT 12218 12225 captive captive JJ 12226 12231 camps camp NNS 12232 12238 should should MD 12239 12243 have have VB 12244 12250 enough enough JJ 12251 12255 room room NN 12256 12259 for for IN 12260 12264 this this DT 12265 12272 purpose purpose NN 12272 12273 . . . 12274 12277 The the DT 12278 12281 use use NN 12282 12284 of of IN 12285 12292 tobacco tobacco NN 12293 12298 shall shall MD 12299 12301 be be VB 12302 12311 permitted permit VBN 12311 12312 . . . 12319 12323 They they PRP 12324 12329 shall shall MD 12330 12332 be be VB 12333 12338 tried try VBN 12339 12343 with with IN 12344 12346 US US NNP 12347 12355 soldiers soldier NNS 12356 12358 in in IN 12359 12362 the the DT 12363 12367 same same JJ 12368 12373 court court NN 12374 12377 for for IN 12378 12381 war war NN 12382 12387 crime crime NN 12387 12388 . . . 12389 12394 There there EX 12395 12401 should should MD 12402 12404 be be VB 12405 12406 a a DT 12407 12411 jury jury NN 12411 12412 , , , 12413 12416 and and CC 12417 12421 they they PRP 12422 12425 are be VBP 12426 12434 entitled entitle VBN 12435 12437 to to TO 12438 12444 appeal appeal VB 12444 12445 . . . 12452 12463 Attachments attachment NNS 12463 12464 : : : 12465 12477 zm0131cc.pdf zm0131cc.pdf NN